Pickup artists (PUA) are notorious for treating women like prey, by using calculated verbal manipulation. They're suave, smooth and will leave you blushing, until you wake up alone the next morning and fume at what an asshole he was when you thought you meant something to him. You did. For one night only.
But YourTango writer Matthew Hoelscher says that these guys would actually make awesome life partners. He argues that PUAs have "truly considered what it means to be committed" before they settle down, have superior communication skills (they actually talk to women!), and have a better understanding of "the intricacies of human nature."
We don't totally buy that. And there are
reasons why:
1. Putting women down is part of the game.
"Negging," according to Jesse Charger, the man behind PUA blog Seduction Science, involves making a woman feel self-conscious or insulting her. Charger advises that this will "lower a girl’s social value in relation to yours," and help the PUA “stand out as socially valuable male and a challenge.”
One such example, according to Seduction Science: “I like your eyes. Hey… are you wearing colored contacts??? (before she can answer) Oh my god, no way, you are…”
2. The PUA community publishes literature which implies that consent is irrelevant.
A controversial Kickstarter campaign for a pickup book called Above The Game suggested that readers forget "asking for permission" to be physical with a woman. "Be dominant," it advised. "Force her to rebuff your advances.” Author Ken Hoinsky also wrote:
All the greatest seducers in history could not keep their hands off of women. They aggressively escalated physically with every woman they were flirting with. They began touching them immediately, kept great body language and eye contact, and were shameless in their physicality. Even when a girl rejects your advances, she KNOWS that you desire her. That’s hot. It arouses her physically and psychologically.
3. They take “alpha behavior” to a whole new level.
Case in point: The “reckless disaster” method the Seduction Science blog recommends PUAs -- and wannabe PUAs -- use to pick up "fly girls." According to Charger, “Hot women want to be dominated, want to feel cheap and want to be used by a strong man who isn’t looking for her permission or approval.”
4. The PUA community often judges women solely based on their appearances.
PUA forums often refer to potential "targets" (i.e. women) by their "number" -- a hotness score assigned on a scale of one to 10. Because obviously a woman's worth can be easily defined by how many "slightly exaggerated facial features" she has.
5. This "advice."