The Reason Automakers Are Dropping Manual Transmissions
Sep 12, 2013 13:07
Why are so many automakers dropping manual transmissions from their lineups? It turns out, they it is the expensive software to blame. While the transmissions may be simple and cheap to manufacture, the integration cost is sky high.
Total recalibration is required for a new car's computer systems to accept a three pedal gearbox. According to an industry insider:
Well, I can offer you some insight from my experience fighting for this from the inside of an OEM.
To develop, test, homologate, and certify an MTX [manual transmission - Ed.] variant of a vehicle platform is very costly. Probably more costly than the borderline MTX enthusiast might be willing to pay. It's not just the hardware which can get costly for a well synthesized box - It's the software. Whether we like it or not, software drives modern day cars. Engine, Transmission, and ESP/ABS/TCS systems all run on software. Sure, the base software for the control systems can be carried over, but the calibration for these systems is not trivial by any means, and requires significant man-years of development and several prototype test properties in multiple environments to develop, test, and certify performance and safety.
I knew a seasoned vehicle calibrator in the company, and he showed me a graph with an exponential curve fit through several data points. The X-axis was vehicle model year. The Y-axis was the number of calibration set points required for _just_ the engine calibration. In the 1980's it was up to 10. By the late 1990's it was in the 10,000's and the trend was climbing steeply. This didn't even consider yet the ESP/ABS/TCS systems which have also grown in complexity over the past decade. Add several tens of thousands more calibration points for them.
Most of the auto manufacturers do a 'value added' calculation to assess vehicle program feasibility / profitability. Unfortunately, when you consider the cost of the per-vehicle parts and development/test/homologation/certification amortized over the volume of a low take-rate option like MTX, it doesn't paint a good picture.
I fought long and hard for enthusiast oriented content during my career there, only to find that it was difficult to (believe it or not) get some product planners to appreciate the importance of the enthusiast market since enthusiasts serve as taste makers for the main stream.
So, all of you MTX fan boys and girls out there, keep buying new cars with MTX's. That's the only way to ensure that product planners can justify this kind of content. When the take-rates fall below 5%, it becomes a tough sell.
Owning a car is a wonderful, liberating thing to do. You can go wherever you want, whenever you want (well, within reason), and for most of us that take the jump into car ownership, we never leave it behind. There’s plenty of benefits to public transport of course, but nothing quite compares to being able to have your own space, does it? Read more
It’s fair to say that not all drivers are equal. Some of us make silly mistakes on the road and while it’s easy to disregard these issues as basic human error, they are quite dangerous. The majority of incidents on the road could have been prevented by one or more drivers. Just look at the case of the self driving car crash. An investigation found that the driver had seven seconds to intervene before the car collided with a wall. He just wasn’t paying attention and that’s only one of the most common errors that occurs on the road. Read more
When it comes to selling your car, you’ll want the most cash possible from the sale. You’ll also want to find a suitable buyer as soon as possible. Sometimes you’ll get lucky using AutoTrader or another website online. Maybe those newspaper ads managed to encourage someone to give you a call in only a few days. However, when that doesn’t happen, you’ll have to start thinking outside of the box. You’ll find three innovative ideas on this page that could help you to sell your vehicle and get the cash fast. There are no guarantees, but these suggestions could provide the desired outcome when nothing else works. Read more